Threat Eraser
Windows 10 & 11 Buy license · $69.95
Ransomware

Should you pay a ransomware ransom? The risks and the alternatives

Thinking of paying a ransomware ransom? Understand the risks, why law enforcement advises against it, and the recovery options to try first.

Updated 4 minute read The Threat Eraser team

In most cases you should not pay a ransomware ransom. Payment does not guarantee you will get your files back, it funds further attacks, it can mark you as a target for a repeat attack, and in some situations it may even be illegal. Law enforcement agencies, including the FBI, advise victims not to pay and to report the attack instead.

That said, the decision is rarely simple when your photos, accounts or business records are locked. This guide sets out the risks honestly and the alternatives to try first.

Why paying is risky

  • There is no guarantee. You are dealing with criminals. Some never send a key, some send one that only partly works, and some decryption tools are slow or damaged files beyond repair.
  • You may be targeted again. Attackers share information about who pays. A victim who pays once may be seen as a likely payer in future.
  • Your data may still be leaked. Many groups now steal copies of files before encrypting them and threaten to publish them. Paying does not prove they have deleted anything.
  • The malware is still there. A decryption key unlocks files; it does not remove the ransomware or the trojan or backdoor that let it in.
  • Legal problems. Some ransomware groups are subject to sanctions. Paying them can break the law in some countries, and businesses may face questions from regulators or insurers.
  • It is expensive. The Sophos State of Ransomware 2025 report put the median ransom payment by organisations at $1 million. Demands to home users are smaller but still significant.

Alternatives to try before considering payment

  1. Check your backups. An external drive that was unplugged during the attack, a NAS with snapshots, or cloud storage with version history may hold clean copies. On OneDrive, Microsoft 365 subscribers can use Settings > Options > Restore your OneDrive on the OneDrive website to roll files back to a date before the attack.
  2. Check Previous Versions. Right-click a folder in File Explorer, choose Properties and open the Previous Versions tab. Ransomware often deletes these, but not always.
  3. Look for a free decryptor. The No More Ransom project, backed by law enforcement and security companies, can identify many ransomware strains from a ransom note or sample file and offers free decryption tools for some of them. Use a clean device.
  4. Get professional help. A reputable IT support company or incident response firm may be able to recover data or confirm whether a free decryptor applies.
  5. Accept the loss of some files. Painful as it is, starting again with clean files is often cheaper and safer than paying.

Comparing your options

OptionCostChance of recoveryMain risk
Restore from offline backupTime onlyHigh, if the backup is recentLosing changes since the last backup
Free decryptorFreeOnly for some strainsNone, if downloaded from a trusted source
Professional recoveryVariesVariesCost, with no guarantee
Pay the ransomHighUncertainRepeat attacks, leaks, legal issues, malware remains

If you are still considering it

If there is truly no backup and the files are critical, some organisations do decide to pay. If you are in that position:

  • Report the attack first. In the US that means the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3); elsewhere, your national police or cyber-crime reporting service.
  • Speak to your insurer, if you have cyber insurance, and to a lawyer if you are a business.
  • Do not deal with the attackers alone. Professional negotiators and incident responders know how these groups behave.
  • Whatever happens, remove the malware fully before restoring or decrypting anything.
Remember: Paying a ransom never makes the PC clean. Plan to scan thoroughly, or wipe and reinstall Windows, either way.

Make sure you never have to decide

The real answer to "should I pay?" is to make it irrelevant. With a disconnected backup, ransomware becomes an inconvenience rather than a disaster. Our guide on how to protect files from ransomware explains how to set that up, and what to do if you get ransomware covers the full recovery process. Small businesses should also read ransomware protection for small business.

How Threat Eraser helps whether or not you pay

Whatever you decide, the PC needs to be cleaned before you trust it again. A Threat Eraser Full Scan checks every fixed drive for known ransomware, trojans, backdoors and remote-access tools, using file-hash matching, byte-pattern signatures and malware detection rules, including inside ZIP archives, and your files are scanned on your PC rather than uploaded. With a license you can quarantine and erase what it finds and export a report to share with your IT support or insurer.

For the future, the licensed Ransomware Early Warning alerts you when many files in your watched folders are renamed or rewritten quickly, or when ransom notes appear, so you can disconnect before the damage spreads. It does not decrypt files, and no tool offers complete protection, but an early warning combined with an offline backup means you are far less likely to face this choice again.

Find out more about the Threat Eraser malware scanner.

Frequently asked questions

Is it illegal to pay a ransomware ransom?

It is not illegal everywhere, but paying groups that are under sanctions can break the law. Businesses should take legal advice first.

Do attackers always send the decryption key?

No. Some never do, and keys that are sent may only work partly or slowly.

Where can I find a free ransomware decryptor?

The No More Ransom project, backed by law enforcement and security firms, offers free decryptors for some ransomware strains.

Get three guides like this every month, plus software update notices.Subscribe →